This text has undergone thorough fact-checking to ensure accuracy and reliability. All information presented is backed by verified sources and reputable data. By adhering to stringent fact-checking standards, we aim to provide you with reliable and trustworthy content. You can trust the information presented here to make informed decisions with confidence.
Looking for the best debt collection agency? Here's a quick guide to help you choose the right one. Debt collection agencies assist businesses in recovering overdue accounts, with recovery rates ranging from 20% to 60%, depending on the agency and debt type. The right agency can help protect your reputation while improving cash flow.
| Agency | Key Features | Fee Structure | Industries Served |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fair Capital | A+ BBB rating, HIPAA compliance | 20%-40% contingency | Consumer, commercial, medical |
| Summit A•R | Compassionate approach, high recovery rates | 7.5%-50% contingency | Medical, landlords, veterinary |
| IC System | Long history, flexible pricing | 25%-50% contingency | Healthcare, utilities, small business |
| American Profit Recovery | Flat-fee option, customer-friendly tactics | Flat fee or 20%-50% contingency | Small businesses, restoration companies |
Key Takeaway: Choose an agency based on your industry, debt type, and whether you prioritize maintaining customer relationships or faster recovery rates. Each agency has unique strengths to align with your needs.
Top 4 Debt Collection Agencies Comparison: Fees, Recovery Rates, and Specializations
Fair Capital is a full-service agency that focuses on consumer, commercial, and healthcare (medical) debt collection. The agency uses advanced tools like Recovery Scoring and skip tracing to locate debtors and prioritize accounts effectively. Below, we’ll look at their strengths in technology, compliance, and their client-focused fee structures.
Fair Capital holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and has been accredited since April 2019. This reflects its commitment to ethical practices [12,14]. On Google, the agency boasts a 5/5 star rating, with clients frequently highlighting its strong communication skills and ability to deliver results. It’s also a member of ACA International and the New York State Collectors Association (NYSCA), organizations that promote fair treatment of debtors [12,15].
Fair Capital reports having one of the highest success rates in the debt collection industry. Tom Logan, CEO of Cohley, shared his experience, saying, "the team is highly communicative, professional, and, most importantly, effective!" The agency uses a Strategic Collection Flow that includes soft, standard, and intensive collection strategies to achieve the best results. For medical debt, Fair Capital ensures HIPAA compliance and employs specific measures to protect sensitive patient information [16,17].
Fair Capital operates on a "No Money, No Fee" basis, charging clients only when they successfully recover debts [16,19]. Their fees typically range from 20% to 40%, depending on factors like the debt’s age, account balance, account volume, and the industry involved. If legal action is required, additional costs may apply for in-house or affiliated legal services [16,18].
Operating since 1996, Summit A•R has recovered over $160 million for its clients while maintaining an impressively low consumer complaint rate of just 0.02%. The agency follows a "P.H.D. Philosophy" (Preserve Human Dignity), which prioritizes respectful and compassionate communication over aggressive tactics. This philosophy is especially effective for industries like medical offices, landlords, and veterinary practices, where maintaining good client relationships is essential. These credentials highlight why Summit A•R is a standout in its field.
Summit A•R holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and boasts over 100 Google reviews, averaging a perfect 5 out of 5 stars as of March 2023. Skye Schooley from Business.com notes:
Summit A•R (Summit Account Resolution) is our choice as the best collection agency for small businesses, as it offers transparent fees and tailored strategies.
The agency reports recovery rates that are nearly double the industry average across various sectors. Over the last year, it successfully resolved more than 25,300 accounts, often recovering funds within 90 days. Summit A•R also offers credit bureau reporting to all three major bureaus and provides litigation support when traditional methods fall short.
Summit A•R’s fee structure is designed with flexibility and client convenience in mind. It operates on a contingency basis, meaning no upfront or sign-up fees are required. Fees range from 7.5% to 50%, depending on factors like the debt’s age, type, and balance amount. If litigation is necessary, additional fees apply but only after obtaining written consent from the client. The agency also provides skip-tracing services, managed by an on-site licensed private investigator, at no extra cost. Clients can access a secure online portal 24/7 to monitor account statuses, submit new accounts, and generate custom reports.
Summit A•R focuses on collections for medical and dental practices, commercial (B2B) accounts, consumer (B2C) accounts, and employee reimbursements. For medical and dental clients, the agency offers HIPAA-compliant portals and patient-friendly communication. It also caters to niche sectors like commercial tenants, education and tuition recovery, veterinary practices, and residential apartment complexes. Kat Tretina from Investopedia highlights:
For businesses that work directly with consumers on a continued basis, such as medical offices, landlords, and veterinarians, Summit Account Resolution (Summit A•R) can help you collect the money that is owed to you without damaging the relationship you have with your customers.
Established in 1938, IC System is a third-generation, family-owned collection agency that boasts an impressive 99.99996% complaint-free rate - just 6 complaints out of 14 million digital interactions. On average, the agency’s clients stay with them for 16 years, highlighting their long-standing relationships.
IC System has earned an A+ rating and full accreditation from the Better Business Bureau (BBB). In 2021, the agency received the prestigious BBB Torch Award for Ethics. More recently, they were honored with the 2025 AAHAM National President's Award for their leadership in healthcare strategy.
IC System offers two main pricing options to suit different business needs:
These pricing structures are designed to handle a wide variety of debt types and client needs.
IC System focuses on collections for industries like healthcare (including dental and veterinary practices), utilities, telecommunications, government agencies, and small to medium-sized businesses. Their industry-specific approach ensures effective recovery strategies tailored to each sector. They exclusively work with original creditors and hold licenses to operate in all 50 U.S. states, as well as Guam and Puerto Rico.
The agency employs its OmniTouch Engagement Strategy, which blends automated communications - such as texts, emails, and letters - with live, U.S.-based calls to improve contact rates. Additional services include:
Clients can also track recovery progress and performance metrics in real time through a secure online portal. This combination of tools and services ensures a comprehensive approach to debt collection.
American Profit Recovery (APR) takes a thoughtful and cost-conscious approach to debt collection. Since its founding in October 2003, APR has built a solid reputation in the industry, spanning over two decades. With offices in Farmington Hills, Michigan, and Franklin, Massachusetts, the company recently acquired All Debt Solutions, strengthening its presence in both local and national markets.
Although APR is not accredited by the Better Business Bureau (BBB), it boasts an impressive 4.9/5 star rating on Google, based on about 3,700 reviews. Customers frequently highlight the company's clear communication, expertise, and the professionalism of its staff during account setup and training. While there are some consumer complaints listed on the BBB site, APR consistently addresses these concerns with detailed responses.
APR is known for offering an affordable debt collection solution tailored to small businesses, aiming to help them achieve a better return on investment. While exact rates are not publicly disclosed, industry-standard contingency fees typically range between 20% and 50%, depending on factors like the size and age of the debt. APR promotes its pricing as a more efficient alternative to traditional models, which can sometimes take up to half of recovered funds.
APR takes a customer-focused approach, prioritizing empathy and respect when working with consumers to resolve debts. This method helps maintain positive business relationships while improving cash flow for clients. The company also has specialized expertise in assisting restoration companies, which often face unique challenges with late payments and cash flow management.
Clients benefit from a web-based portal that allows them to monitor accounts and track collection activities in real time. Rather than relying on aggressive tactics like high-volume calls, APR focuses on active listening and understanding, encouraging consumers to settle their debts amicably. This approach not only aids in recovery but also helps preserve the client’s reputation and customer relationships.
Here's a breakdown of the strengths and weaknesses for Fair Capital, Summit Account Resolution, IC System, and American Profit Recovery:
| Agency | Key Strengths | Key Weaknesses |
|---|---|---|
| Fair Capital | Maintains an A+ BBB rating; operates on a "no recovery, no fee" model; performs well in consumer, commercial, and healthcare collections | Limited to certain regions; may escalate collection efforts if initial soft tactics don’t succeed |
| Summit Account Resolution | Offers negotiable rates ranging from 7% to 50%; emphasizes a "Preserving Human Dignity" philosophy; provides real-time tracking via a full dashboard | Declines debts that are older than two years |
| IC System | Brings over 80 years of experience; offers tiered pricing, including a $14.95 flat fee or a 25% contingency for more aggressive recovery | Has a ConsumerAffairs rating of 1.0/5 due to aggressive tactics; credit bureau reporting may harm debtor relationships |
| American Profit Recovery | Uses an affordable flat-fee system; focuses on a diplomatic approach to maintain business-consumer relationships; holds a 4.3/5 editorial score | Non-aggressive methods may lead to slower debt recovery |
Summit Account Resolution and IC System stand out for their transparent pricing structures, while American Profit Recovery's flat-fee system offers cost predictability. Each agency's unique approach caters to different business priorities, whether it's maintaining relationships or ensuring efficient recovery.
When selecting a debt collection agency, it's essential to weigh their expertise against your specific needs. Here are some key points to guide your decision.
For medical and healthcare debt, agencies like American Profit Recovery excel with their considerate strategies aimed at maintaining patient relationships. Recovery rates in this sector typically range between 35% and 45%.
If you're tackling consumer or credit card debt, consider agencies such as IC System and Fair Capital. IC System employs assertive measures, including credit bureau reporting, while Fair Capital takes a more empathetic approach, reflected in their A+ BBB rating.
Handling commercial (B2B) debt requires agencies familiar with trade credit intricacies. Look for those that prioritize maintaining professional relationships while ensuring compliance with regulations like FDCPA, FCRA, and TCPA.
Fee structures vary widely, from contingency-based models (20%-50%) to flat fees, tailored to different types of debt and business requirements. Agencies offering transparent pricing, along with advanced tools like 24/7 online portals and real-time tracking, can significantly improve the recovery process. Additionally, agencies with low unresolved CFPB complaint rates and strong BBB ratings help protect your business's reputation.
Lastly, consider the timeline for recovery. Agencies like American Profit Recovery may take a more gradual approach to safeguard customer relationships, while others with aggressive methods might expedite collections on older accounts. Keep in mind that sending an account to collections often signals a strained business relationship.
Typically, an account should be sent to collections once it’s been overdue for 30 to 90 days. This window gives the debtor a fair chance to settle their payment while allowing you to act quickly, depending on your company’s policies and the nature of the debt.
Choosing between a flat fee and a contingency fee comes down to the type of debt you're dealing with and your specific goals. With contingency fees, you pay a percentage - usually between 20% and 50% - of the amount recovered. This option is often better for older debts or those that are more difficult to collect. On the other hand, flat fees involve an upfront cost, typically ranging from $10 to $50 per account, making them a good fit for smaller or newer debts. To make the right choice, think about the age and size of your debts and how much risk you're willing to take.
To safeguard your brand during the debt collection process, it's essential to stay compliant with key regulations like the FDCPA, HIPAA, and GLBA. Partnering with agencies that prioritize data security - through measures like encryption and multi-factor authentication - is a smart move. Additionally, ensure they use empathetic and well-scripted communication to handle sensitive situations professionally.
Take time to review their policies, training logs, quality assurance processes, and complaint management workflows. These precautions not only protect your reputation but also help minimize risks while maintaining a high standard of professionalism throughout the debt collection process.
More than a decade of Ivan's career has been dedicated to Finance, Banking and Digital Solutions. From these three areas, the idea of a fintech solution called Debepxert was born. He started his career in Big Four consulting and continued in the industry, working as a CFO for publicly traded and digital companies. Ivan came into the debt industry in 2019, when company Debexpert started its first operations. Over the past few years the company, following his lead, has become a technological leader in the US, opened its offices in 10 countries and achieved a record level of sales - 700 debt portfolios per year.
.svg){kind=icon}
.svg){kind=icon}
.svg){kind=icon}
