Buy and Sell debt portfolios online

Investment Attractiveness of Solar Loan Portfolios in Different Geographic Regions

Fact checked
Read time:
3
min

This text has undergone thorough fact-checking to ensure accuracy and reliability. All information presented is backed by verified sources and reputable data. By adhering to stringent fact-checking standards, we aim to provide you with reliable and trustworthy content. You can trust the information presented here to make informed decisions with confidence.

Author:
Table of contents

Solar loan investments vary significantly by region in the U.S., influenced by sunlight availability, electricity prices, and state policies. Here’s a quick overview of the key takeaways:

  • Southwest: High sunlight, lower electricity costs, and state incentives like the 30% ITC make it a top choice for long-term investments. Time-of-use pricing drives returns.
  • Northeast: High electricity rates offset lower sunlight levels. States like Massachusetts and New Jersey offer strong savings potential, making this region attractive despite higher installation costs.
  • Midwest: Emerging market with growing regulatory support and innovative financing options. States like Illinois and Indiana are leading solar adoption, despite moderate sunlight availability.

Quick Comparison

Region Sunlight (kWh/m²/day) Electricity Cost ($/kWh) Key Drivers
Southwest 6.5–7.5 $0.0951 High IRR from sunlight and incentives
Northeast 4.0–4.5 $0.2576 High electricity rates
Midwest 4.5–5.5 $0.1015 Regulatory advancements, financing

Key Insight: Diversify solar investments across regions to balance risk and maximize returns. Focus on areas with stable policies, high electricity prices, or strong sunlight exposure.

Renewable Energy Project Finance Basics with Josh Pearson ’97

1. Southwest U.S. Market Analysis

The Southwest U.S. stands out as a prime area for solar loan portfolios, thanks to its abundant sunlight and favorable state policies. For example, Nevada's electricity prices are about 50% lower than California's, even though both states have a similar share of solar energy. This makes the region an interesting case for examining tariff structures and policy impacts.

While high solar irradiance is a key factor, the real driver of financial performance in solar projects lies in electricity tariff structures. This is especially true during peak demand periods, such as hot summer days when air conditioning use spikes. These tariffs play a crucial role in maintaining consistent Internal Rate of Return (IRR), making the region appealing for long-term investments.

The IRR metric provides a better measure of investment potential than the traditional Levelized Cost of Electricity (LCOE), as it considers time-of-use electricity pricing - a critical factor in this market.

Factor Impact on Investment Returns
Solar Irradiance High, with minimal variation across 25 locations
Time-of-Use Pricing Major influence on IRR variations
State Incentives Projects may qualify for a 30% ITC or a 2.6¢/kWh PTC

In March 2023, Nevada's Governor's Office approved a $330 million tax break for Tesla's $3.6 billion expansion of Giga Nevada, highlighting the state's dedication to renewable energy. This commitment brings several key factors into focus for investors:

  • Time-of-Use Pricing: Peak demand periods can significantly affect potential returns.
  • Technology Choice: Concentrated Photovoltaic (CPV) systems often yield higher IRR compared to traditional photovoltaic (PV) systems.
  • State-Level Incentives: Projects starting construction before 2033 may qualify for tax credits like the 30% Investment Tax Credit or the 2.6¢/kWh Production Tax Credit.

Interestingly, the Southwest shows that higher adoption of renewable energy doesn't necessarily lead to higher electricity prices. For instance, New Mexico combines a high level of solar energy use with competitive electricity rates, thanks to supportive policies.

Investors should carefully align discount rates with projected IRR to evaluate financial feasibility. Incorporating time-of-use pricing into this analysis strengthens the financial outlook and underscores the strategic advantage of investing in the Southwest U.S. solar market.

2. Northeast U.S. Market Analysis

The Northeast U.S. stands out as a prime area for solar loan investments, largely due to its high electricity costs. This makes it a compelling alternative to the Southwest, which relies more on abundant sunlight.

Take Massachusetts, for example. Electricity costs here are $0.22/kWh - among the highest in the country - with estimated annual solar savings of $1,441. Interestingly, these savings are achieved despite the state’s moderate solar radiation levels of 4.88 kWh/m²/day.

Here’s a breakdown of key performance metrics for major Northeast states:

State Annual Solar Savings Electricity Cost System Production (5kW)
Massachusetts $1,441 $0.22/kWh 6,574 kWh
New York $1,122 $0.18/kWh 6,255 kWh
New Jersey $1,086 $0.16/kWh 6,849 kWh

Over the past decade, residential electricity costs in the region have risen by 21%, further enhancing the appeal of solar investments by allowing homeowners to lock in lower energy costs.

For example, New Jersey's 5kW system generates about 2,000 kWh less annually than a similar system in Colorado. However, New Jersey homeowners still see comparable savings - around $1,060 annually - thanks to the higher electricity rates.

Even in areas with fewer sunny days, like New York, annual savings of $1,122 are possible due to elevated electricity costs. This highlights the Northeast's strong potential for solar loan investments, offering attractive returns that balance risk and reward.

For investors looking to diversify their portfolios, the Northeast provides a solid opportunity, complementing the Southwest's advantages in solar resource availability. This analysis lays the groundwork for comparing regional investment returns on a broader scale.

sbb-itb-23a5340

3. Midwest U.S. Market Analysis

The Midwest is emerging as a notable region for solar investments, thanks to evolving regulations and growing financial support. Illinois leads the way with 2,823 megawatts of solar production, though in most Midwestern states, solar contributes less than 2% to total electricity generation.

Regulatory Landscape in Key States

Here’s how some Midwestern states are shaping their solar policies:

State Regulatory Framework Solar Growth Potential Key Features
Illinois Statewide binding standards High (Top 10 nationally) Features the Climate & Equitable Jobs Act
Indiana Voluntary state standards High (Top 10 nationally) "Solar ready" community designation
Ohio Local control enhanced High (Top 10 nationally) County-level authority over project siting
Michigan State-level oversight Moderate Oversight for projects over 50 MW by state commission

Financing Innovations Driving Growth

New financing models are making the Midwest increasingly attractive for solar development. For example, Greenpenny, a regional lender, offers solar loans averaging $40,000 with straightforward terms and no hidden fees. Local financial institutions, like Greenpenny and All Energy Solar, emphasize the importance of accessible financing in driving renewable energy projects:

"For us to accomplish the renewable energy transition this country needs, we need more banks to be in the game helping finance these projects"

"Historically, we find the national players driving continuous innovation and competing with each other to offer a diverse array of financing options that will help each customer to get the most value out of their project"

Policy Highlights and Future Outlook

States with forward-thinking policies are setting the stage for further growth. In Indiana, SB 411 (2022) introduced voluntary siting and zoning criteria, allowing communities to earn a "solar ready" designation. Additionally, SB 390 (2023) established a financial incentive fund, offering $1 per megawatt-hour over a 10-year period. Meanwhile, Illinois’ Climate & Equitable Jobs Act requires counties with zoning standards to hold public hearings within 45 days of a project application being submitted.

Although the Midwest receives less solar radiation compared to the Southwest, regulatory advancements and innovative financing options are making it a promising market. The Solar Energy Industries Association predicts increased solar production across all Midwestern states over the next five years.

Community banks and credit unions are also stepping up by aligning loan payments with utility savings, making solar projects more accessible. These efforts are boosting returns and positioning the Midwest as an appealing choice for solar investment portfolios.

Investment Comparison by Region

This section highlights key metrics and revenue trends across solar loan portfolios, focusing on regional differences influenced by geography.

Market Performance Indicators

Solar performance varies significantly by region. The Southwest generates 2,180 MWh/MWp annually, compared to 1,500 MWh/MWp in the Northeast.

Performance Metric Southwest Northeast Midwest
Annual Sun Exposure 6.5–7.5 kWh/m²/day 4.0–4.5 kWh/m²/day 4.5–5.5 kWh/m²/day
Commercial Electric Rate $0.0951/kWh $0.2576/kWh $0.1015/kWh

Revenue Dynamics

High electricity rates in the Northeast - up to $0.2576/kWh in Connecticut - help offset lower sunlight levels. Meanwhile, the Southwest benefits from wholesale price advantages, with California solar PV reaching $100/MWh compared to the $36/MWh national average.

Regional Investment Insights

Southwest Markets:

  • Experience a price drop of –$0.39/MWh for every GWh produced.
  • Tracker systems improve yields by 20%.
  • Account for 58% of North American solar bond issuances.

Northeast Markets:

  • SREC markets offer $180–$220/MWh returns.
  • Capacity markets in ISO-NE add 12–18% to revenue.
  • Higher installation costs are offset by elevated electricity rates.

Midwest Markets:

  • Features manufacturing growth, including OCI Holdings' $265M facility in Georgia.
  • MISO region added 2.7 GWAC capacity in 2023.
  • State-level production credits help balance lower electricity rates.

Storage Integration Impact

Battery storage is reshaping investment strategies. In California, a new 3-hour storage mandate starting in 2025 will increase project costs by 12–15% but could boost PPA pricing by 28%. In the Northeast, storage-integrated projects deliver 9–11% higher ROI, while the Midwest sees a smaller 2–3% premium. These factors significantly influence risk and return, emphasizing the importance of tailored regional strategies.

Market Structure Influence

State incentives and market structures play a key role in shaping returns. For instance, Southwest projects within ERCOT benefit from 8¢/kWh peak summer pricing but face a 15% curtailment risk. Northeast ISO-NE capacity auctions add 12–18% to revenue, while Midwest MISO ancillary services contribute an additional 5–9%.

Key Findings and Recommendations

Solar loan portfolios have shown steady growth and resilience, with securitization volumes increasing from $1.4 billion in 2016 to $8.6 billion in 2022. This analysis highlights strategies to fine-tune regional investments for better outcomes.

Portfolio Performance Metrics

Solar loans have consistently outperformed traditional lending products. For example, 90-day delinquencies for solar loans are just 0.18%, compared to 0.50% for mortgages and 3.73% for auto loans. These loans also deliver higher returns, offering 200-400 basis points more than conventional mortgage and auto loans.

Geographic Diversification Strategy

While spreading investments across regions is important, focusing on a few key states can balance returns and risk effectively. Here's a suggested approach:

Portfolio Component Suggested Strategy Risk Factor to Address
Geographic Spread Limit to 3-4 states Reduces exposure to regulatory changes
Credit Quality Average FICO score of 740+ Lowers likelihood of defaults
Project Mix Blend of residential and C&I Improves overall stability

This combination helps manage risks while boosting returns.

Risk Mitigation Framework

"Geographic concentration of loans among a relative handful of states is another major risk consideration for residential solar financiers." - Dallasfed.org

To address this, consider these strategies:

  • Focus on Credit Quality: Set high standards for borrowers, aiming for FICO scores averaging 740 or higher. Past data shows this approach has contributed to the sector's strong performance.
  • Select Stable Markets: Invest in areas with consistent regulatory environments and strong economic conditions. The solar sector's 33% annual growth rate over the last decade highlights its momentum.
  • Diversify Portfolio Composition: Include both residential and commercial/industrial (C&I) projects. This balanced approach reduces risk. Community solar projects, which combine elements of utility-scale, residential, and C&I installations, are particularly appealing.

Investment Sizing Considerations

Portfolio size plays a critical role in achieving optimal returns. It should be large enough to cover transaction costs while maintaining a focused geographic strategy. The rise in securitization volumes reflects strong market liquidity.

For commercial investments, prioritize those with investment-grade ratings or strong termination payment provisions. This approach ensures solid performance and delivers competitive, risk-adjusted returns.

FAQs

How do state-level incentives in the Southwest U.S. influence returns on solar loan investments?

State-level incentives in the Southwest U.S., such as tax credits, rebates, and renewable energy mandates, can significantly enhance the returns on solar loan investments. These incentives often reduce upfront costs for solar installations or provide ongoing financial benefits, making solar projects more attractive to borrowers and increasing the likelihood of timely loan repayments.

Additionally, the Southwest benefits from abundant sunlight and relatively high electricity rates, which further improve the economic case for solar energy. These factors, combined with supportive state policies, contribute to more stable and potentially higher risk-adjusted returns for solar loan portfolios in this region.

Why is the Northeast U.S. considered a strong market for solar loan investments despite having less sunlight compared to other regions?

The Northeast U.S. offers significant opportunities for solar loan investments due to several compelling factors. While the region receives less sunlight compared to sunnier areas like the Southwest, it compensates with higher-than-average electricity rates, which make solar energy a cost-effective alternative for many businesses and homeowners.

Additionally, the Northeast benefits from state-level incentives and policies that promote renewable energy adoption, such as tax credits and net metering programs. The abundance of commercial rooftop space further enhances the potential for mid-scale solar projects, making this region a valuable market for investors seeking stable, long-term returns.

Why is the Midwest becoming an attractive region for solar investments?

The Midwest is quickly emerging as a promising market for solar investments due to several key factors. States like Ohio and Indiana are experiencing significant growth in solar farm developments, driven by increasing support for renewable energy projects. This shift is creating opportunities for developers to install a large number of photovoltaic panels across the region.

Communities are embracing solar energy thanks to its low costs and the potential for job creation in construction and manufacturing. Additionally, the Midwest benefits from ample land availability and evolving regulatory frameworks that encourage investments in clean energy. These trends make the region a compelling option for investors seeking stable, long-term returns in the solar sector.

Related posts

Investment Attractiveness of Solar Loan Portfolios in Different Geographic Regions
Written by
Ivan Korotaev
Debexpert CEO, Co-founder

More than a decade of Ivan's career has been dedicated to Finance, Banking and Digital Solutions. From these three areas, the idea of a fintech solution called Debepxert was born. He started his career in  Big Four consulting and continued in the industry, working as a CFO for publicly traded and digital companies. Ivan came into the debt industry in 2019, when company Debexpert started its first operations. Over the past few years the company, following his lead, has become a technological leader in the US, opened its offices in 10 countries and achieved a record level of sales - 700 debt portfolios per year.

  • Big Four consulting
  • Expert in Finance, Banking and Digital Solutions
  • CFO for publicly traded and digital companies

FAQ

No items found.

What debt are we selling

We specialize in car, real estate, consumer and credit cards loans. We can sell any kind of debt.

Other debt portfolios for sale

Interested in buying or selling debt portfolios?
Let's connect! Fill out this form 👇