This text has undergone thorough fact-checking to ensure accuracy and reliability. All information presented is backed by verified sources and reputable data. By adhering to stringent fact-checking standards, we aim to provide you with reliable and trustworthy content. You can trust the information presented here to make informed decisions with confidence.
Debt collection agencies help businesses recover overdue payments when internal efforts fail. These agencies contact borrowers through calls, emails, or letters, negotiate settlements, or pursue legal action if necessary. They operate under strict regulations, such as the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA), which prohibits abusive or deceptive practices. Agencies typically work on a commission basis, earning 25%-50% of recovered funds, and their strategies include asset searches, payment plans, and legal enforcement.
Key Points:
For businesses, choosing a licensed and compliant agency is essential to minimize financial loss and protect reputation.
A debt collection agency is a company that creditors or lenders hire to recover money from overdue accounts. Acting as a go-between, these agencies focus on collecting payments that businesses have been unable to retrieve on their own.
Debt collection agencies can operate in several ways. Some function as in-house teams (known as first-party departments) that handle collections during the early stages, typically within the first six months. Others work as third-party agents, earning commissions that range from 25% to 60% of the recovered amount. There are also debt buyers, who purchase delinquent accounts for a fraction of their value and then try to collect the full balance. These different approaches allow agencies to tailor their strategies based on the specific needs of creditors.
This industry is substantial, employing over 40,000 people and generating $13 billion annually. It affects around 77 million Americans, with the average individual debt sitting at $5,178.
Debt collection agencies play a key role in helping creditors reduce financial losses. Instead of allocating their own resources to chase overdue payments, creditors rely on these agencies to recover funds more efficiently. By using specialized methods, agencies aim to maximize the amount recovered.
Their strategies include conducting asset searches to locate financial accounts and, when necessary, pursuing legal action to obtain court judgments. These judgments can authorize measures like wage garnishment or bank levies. This comprehensive approach ensures that creditors recover funds they might otherwise have to write off. The contingency fee model - where agencies are paid only when they successfully recover money - ensures their goals are closely aligned with those of the creditors.
Once an agency is engaged, the recovery process begins when an account is assigned for collection. This typically happens when a payment is overdue by 60 to 90 days. Agencies assess accounts to determine which ones are most likely to result in recovery, considering factors like the debtor's credit history and past payment behavior.
Within five days of contacting the debtor, agencies must send a validation notice. This document outlines the debt amount, the creditor's name, and instructions for disputing the debt. Debtors have 30 days to challenge the debt in writing, during which time collection efforts must pause until the agency provides proper verification, such as a copy of the original invoice.
"A debt collector is generally a person or company that regularly collects debts owed to others or who has the primary purpose of collecting debts." - Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
Agencies use multiple methods to reach debtors, including phone calls (restricted to 8:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m.), letters, emails, text messages, and even social media. They may also reach out to a debtor's acquaintances - such as family, friends, or co-workers - but only to verify information like address, phone number, or employment details.
During negotiations, agencies often offer solutions like reduced lump-sum payments or structured payment plans. If these attempts fail, and with the creditor's approval, the agency may escalate the matter by filing a lawsuit. A court judgment could lead to actions like wage garnishment, bank account levies, or property liens. The process concludes when the debt is fully paid, settled for a lesser amount, or discharged through bankruptcy.
Types of Debt Collection Agencies Comparison Chart
When it comes to recovering unpaid debts, three main types of agencies handle the job: traditional agencies, legal agencies, and debt buyers. Each type has its own approach and is suited for different situations.
Traditional agencies act as intermediaries between creditors and debtors, focusing on negotiating payment plans. They’re best for accounts that are 60 to 90 days overdue.
However, these agencies can't take legal action. They don’t have the authority to file lawsuits, garnish wages, or seize bank accounts. What they can do is provide evidence and documentation if the creditor decides to pursue legal action on their own. Most traditional agencies work on a contingency fee basis, taking 25% to 50% of the recovered amount.
This type of agency works well for businesses dealing with a high volume of small debts, such as unpaid utility bills or credit card accounts. Since the creditor keeps ownership of the debt, they must approve any settlement offers that involve less than the full amount owed.
If more aggressive action is needed, legal agencies are the next step.
When debts are larger or harder to collect, legal agencies step in. These agencies are essentially law firms with licensed attorneys who can file lawsuits, obtain court judgments, and enforce collections through measures like wage garnishment or property liens.
"Communication from a lawyer makes a greater impression, thereby increasing the possibility of paying collections." - Debt.org
Legal agencies are often used when traditional methods fail, especially for high-value accounts or cases where the debtor has assets but refuses to pay. The creditor still owns the debt, but the legal agency handles all litigation and enforcement efforts.
For creditors looking to completely offload delinquent accounts, debt buyers offer a different solution. These companies purchase debts outright, usually at a fraction of their original value. Once they own the debt, they take full responsibility for collection.
"The debt buyer then becomes the legal owner of that debt and thus is responsible for all further collection efforts and outcomes." - Danielle Fallon-O'Leary, Contributor, U.S. Chamber of Commerce
This option is ideal for businesses wanting to clear old or "zombie" debts off their books and recover at least a small portion of the loss. Debt buyers often purchase large portfolios - like old credit card balances or medical bills - and may either try to collect the debts themselves or resell them. Unlike traditional or legal agencies, debt buyers have full control over settlement terms and can also sue debtors as the new legal owner of the accounts.
| Agency Type | Legal Authority | Ownership of Debt | Primary Methods | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional | Cannot file lawsuits | Original Creditor | Phone calls, letters, skip tracing | 60–90 days overdue debts |
| Legal (Law Firm) | Can sue and garnish wages | Original Creditor | Lawsuits, court judgments | High-value or difficult cases |
| Debt Buyer | Can sue as the owner | Debt Buyer | Collection or resale | Charged-off or old accounts |
Debt collection agencies operate on a straightforward premise: they only make money when they successfully recover funds. This "no collection, no fee" system ensures that the agency's efforts align with the creditor's goals, as they invest their time and resources without any guaranteed return. Once funds are recovered, the agency deducts its fees from the amount before sending the remainder to the creditor.
The percentage charged as a fee depends on several factors. Debt age plays a key role - newer debts (under 90 days old) often incur fees of around 20%, while older accounts (over a year old) can see rates climb to about 50%. Account size also matters. Smaller debts under $500 typically face fees of 35–45%, while larger balances exceeding $500,000 may qualify for significantly lower rates, often between 10% and 15%. Below, we break down two key revenue streams: the contingency fee model and settlement negotiation fees.
Contingency fees are a cornerstone of the debt collection industry, contributing to about 50% of its $13 billion annual revenue. Success rates vary by industry, with overall recovery rates hovering between 20% and 30%. However, debts under 90 days old sometimes achieve recovery rates as high as 40–60%.
For second-placement accounts - debts that another agency has already attempted to collect without success - fees are higher, typically around 45–50%, reflecting the increased difficulty of recovery. Some agencies also provide flat-fee options, charging between $50 and $300 per account. This approach offers a predictable cost structure, regardless of whether the debt is ultimately recovered. Beyond contingency fees, settlement negotiations contribute another revenue stream.
When full recovery isn't possible, especially with older or more challenging debts, agencies often negotiate settlements. In these cases, the agency takes a commission on the amount recovered through the settlement. This method is particularly effective for aging accounts.
Typically, agencies remit the recovered funds, minus their fees, within 24 to 72 hours of receiving payment from the debtor. Some agencies, however, operate on monthly remittance cycles. With the average debt in collection standing at $5,178 and roughly 77 million Americans having debts in collection, the potential recovery market remains immense.
Debt collection agencies operate under strict federal and state regulations designed to shield consumers from abusive practices. The cornerstone of these rules is the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA), established in 1978. According to the Federal Trade Commission:
"The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) makes it illegal for debt collectors to use abusive, unfair, or deceptive practices when they collect debts."
Non-compliance can result in penalties of up to $1,000 per individual violation, along with court costs and attorney fees. For class action lawsuits, liability is capped at the lesser of $500,000 or 1% of the collector's net worth.
In addition to federal law, agencies must navigate state-specific rules. For instance, while the FDCPA generally excludes original creditors, many states extend protections to include them. Statutes of limitations also vary; in California, debt lawsuits based on written agreements typically have a four-year limit. When state laws offer stronger consumer protections than the FDCPA, collectors must adhere to the stricter standard.
The FDCPA clearly outlines behaviors that debt collectors must avoid. For example, contacting consumers outside the hours of 8:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. local time is prohibited. Additionally, collectors can make no more than seven calls about a specific debt within seven consecutive days. After speaking with a consumer, they must wait at least seven days before calling again.
Harassment and abusive tactics are strictly off-limits. Collectors cannot use threats, profane language, or publicize "shame lists" of debtors. The FDCPA states:
"A debt collector may not engage in any conduct the natural consequence of which is to harass, oppress, or abuse any person in connection with the collection of a debt."
Misrepresentation is another banned practice. Collectors cannot falsely claim to be attorneys, government officials, or law enforcement, nor can they misstate the amount owed or the legal status of a debt. As the FDCPA explains:
"A debt collector may not use any false, deceptive, or misleading representation or means in connection with the collection of any debt."
Restrictions also extend to contacting third parties. Collectors may only reach out to third parties to obtain "location information", such as a consumer's address or workplace, and they must not disclose the existence of a debt. Contacting the same third party more than once is prohibited unless explicitly requested. If a consumer is represented by an attorney, all direct communication with the consumer must stop immediately.
Debt collectors must also send a written "validation notice" within five days of initial contact. This notice must include the debt amount, the creditor's name, and an explanation of the consumer's 30-day right to dispute the debt. If a consumer disputes the debt in writing within that window, collection efforts must pause until written verification is provided. Consumers can also request that all communication cease entirely; after receiving such a request, collectors may only confirm the notice or inform the consumer of any legal actions.
Recent regulatory updates address electronic communication methods. When using email, text messages, or social media, collectors must provide a clear opt-out option and are barred from posting publicly about a debt. They are also prohibited from suing - or threatening to sue - over debts that are time-barred due to expired statutes of limitations.
Protecting consumer data is a critical responsibility for debt collectors. Agencies must comply with federal laws like the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, which governs financial data privacy and breach notifications. For example, collectors cannot use postcards or place debt-related symbols on envelopes, as these could unintentionally reveal a consumer's financial information.
This framework forms the foundation for evaluating collection agencies, which will be explored in the following section.
Picking the right debt collection agency requires careful consideration of their capabilities and adherence to compliance standards. Doing so not only protects your business's reputation but also ensures effective recovery efforts.
Start by confirming the agency is properly licensed, bonded, and certified for the states where they operate. Agencies that focus on consumer debt typically need licensing in all 50 states, while commercial collectors should have certifications from respected organizations like the Commercial Collection Agencies of America (CCA of A), the International Association of Commercial Collectors (IACC), or the Commercial Law League of America (CLLA).
Technology plays a big role in effective debt collection. Look for agencies that provide advanced tools, such as online client portals with real-time updates, skip tracing, and data analytics. For instance, in September 2025, the agency InDebted partnered with Tratta to launch an embedded payments platform, achieving a staggering 1,861% increase in self-service payments - all while staying compliant.
Specialization is another critical factor. Agencies that focus on your specific type of debt are better equipped to navigate regulations and apply the most effective recovery strategies. As Jeremy Crane, author of Retrievables, puts it:
"Choosing an agency that specializes in your debt type ensures they know the relevant regulations and best recovery tactics".
The regulatory framework also deserves attention. Here’s a quick breakdown of key regulations and their impact:
| Regulatory Framework | Key Focus Area | Impact on Business Risk |
|---|---|---|
| FDCPA | Consumer protection from abuse/deception | Prevents harassment and misleading claims |
| TCPA | Phone and text outreach | Controls robocalls and requires prior consent |
| Regulation F | Communication frequency | Limits call attempts and defines recordkeeping |
| FCRA | Credit bureau reporting | Ensures accurate reporting and resolves disputes |
Additionally, confirm the agency has strong insurance coverage, including Errors & Omissions (E&O) insurance and liability protection, to shield your business from legal risks. To avoid dealing with unethical agencies, cross-check potential partners against the Federal Trade Commission’s list of banned debt collectors. With over 150,000 complaints filed each year, this step is critical.
Transparency is key when working with a debt collection agency. Ask for a detailed explanation of their methods, ensure their communication aligns with your brand values, and establish a dedicated point of contact for regular updates. Check the Better Business Bureau for unresolved complaints or legal issues.
Before signing a contract, understand the agency’s fee structure. Contingency fees often range from 15% to 50% of recovered funds, depending on factors like account age, portfolio size, or the need for legal action. Some agencies also offer flat-fee or hybrid pricing models for final demand services.
Make sure the agency follows best practices, such as adhering to the "7-in-7" rule (no more than seven calls about a specific debt within seven days) and contacting debtors only between 8:00 a.m. and 9:00 p.m. local time. They should also wait at least 14 days after sending a validation notice before reporting a debt to credit bureaus.
As Richard Hart, founder of Direct Recovery Associates, Inc., advises:
"Selecting a well-respected debt collection agency is essential to ensuring your business maintains the solid reputation you have worked to build for it".
When an account is overdue by 60 to 180 days, creditors often hand it over to a collection agency for further action. In the first few months of delinquency, creditors usually try to recover the debt themselves through their internal departments. Once they decide to outsource, they provide the collection agency with key details, including the debtor's name, last known address, account number, and a breakdown of the debt. At this stage, agencies often use skip tracing to locate debtors who are difficult to reach. This involves leveraging specialized databases that pull information from public and private records.
"Successful agencies can track down someone who has 'skipped town' through a process called skip tracing. This involves using databases to gather, mine, and verify information on hard-to-reach individuals."
Under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA), collectors are allowed to contact third parties - like neighbors, family members, or coworkers - but only to confirm basic details such as the debtor's home address, phone number, or workplace. They are strictly prohibited from revealing that the individual owes a debt. Additionally, agencies must send a written validation notice to debtors within five days of the initial contact, as required by law.
Once the debtor's location and identity are verified, the agency reaches out through written notices, phone calls, and emails. Collectors must follow strict rules regarding the timing of these contacts, including a general limit of seven calls within a seven-day period. Agencies also use third-party tools to ensure they have the correct contact information while adhering to the Telephone Consumer Protection Act.
During this phase, agencies often propose settlement options, such as reduced lump-sum payments or structured payment plans. If the debtor disputes the debt in writing within 30 days of receiving the validation notice, the agency must pause all collection activities until they verify and confirm the debt. After negotiations, agencies prepare final reports to update creditors and credit bureaus with the latest status of the account.
After negotiations are completed, agencies finalize the process by sending detailed reports to creditors. These reports categorize each account as "paid in full", "settled", or "uncollectible". When a debt is recovered, the agency deducts its commission - usually between 25% and 60% of the collected amount - before transferring the funds to the creditor. The debtor also receives a letter of satisfaction, which serves as legal proof that the debt has been resolved.
The collection agency updates credit bureaus with the new status of the debt, such as "paid" or "settled." However, even when resolved, collection accounts generally remain on credit reports for seven years from the original delinquency date. For debts deemed uncollectible - such as those tied to bankruptcy or cases where the debtor cannot be located - the agency marks them as "charged off." At this point, creditors may decide to stop pursuing further collection efforts. Both creditors and debtors are advised to review their credit reports a few months after resolution to ensure all updates have been accurately reflected.
Choosing the right debt collection agency involves a thoughtful look at compliance, ethics, and overall effectiveness. A key step is reviewing the FTC's banned list before entering into any partnership, as debt collection consistently ranks as the industry with the highest number of fraud reports. For instance, in February 2024, the FTC secured a $20.3 million judgment against RCG Advances, LLC, permanently banning its operator, Jonathan Braun, from the industry for deceiving small businesses and unlawfully seizing assets.
"Debt collectors generate more fraud reports to the FTC than any other industry." – Federal Trade Commission
This level of regulatory oversight not only ensures adherence to the law but also protects your brand from reputational harm. Unethical collection practices can severely damage your brand image and diminish customer trust. Agencies that follow strict compliance standards use modern communication methods and understand the importance of maintaining professionalism. While collection accounts can remain on credit reports for up to seven years, ethical practices safeguard both the creditor's reputation and the debtor's rights.
Transparency and shared goals are key to effective debt recovery. Trustworthy agencies often work on a contingency fee basis, meaning their success is tied directly to your recovery results. To ensure you're working with a reliable partner, confirm that the agency is licensed, bonded, and affiliated with organizations like ACA International. By focusing on compliance and professionalism, businesses can recover overdue debts without compromising their standing in the marketplace.
When unpaid invoices linger beyond 60–90 days and your internal efforts haven’t worked, it might be time to bring in a debt collection agency. These agencies specialize in recovering debts while maintaining a professional approach that helps preserve your client relationships.
Before moving forward, ensure the debt amount is worth the agency’s fees, which are usually a percentage of what they recover. Also, confirm the debt is still within the statute of limitations for collection. Turning to a collection agency is a practical move when other methods have fallen short.
When choosing a debt collection agency, it's crucial to make sure they adhere to legal and ethical guidelines, such as the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. Look into their track record - how much experience do they have, and how successful have they been with cases like yours? Pay attention to their fee structure, the tools they use to track collections, and how they communicate. Transparency and professionalism in these areas are key. Taking the time to evaluate these factors will help you find a trustworthy and effective agency to work with.
To reduce legal and reputational risks in collections, it's crucial to comply with laws like the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA). This law explicitly bans abusive, misleading, or unfair practices in debt collection. Additionally, the Debt Collection Rule requires providing accurate information, steering clear of threats, and properly handling time-barred debts.
Make compliance a priority by training your staff thoroughly, keeping detailed records of all communications, and resolving disputes quickly. These steps not only help you stay within the law but also uphold your agency's reputation for ethical practices.
More than a decade of Ivan's career has been dedicated to Finance, Banking and Digital Solutions. From these three areas, the idea of a fintech solution called Debepxert was born. He started his career in Big Four consulting and continued in the industry, working as a CFO for publicly traded and digital companies. Ivan came into the debt industry in 2019, when company Debexpert started its first operations. Over the past few years the company, following his lead, has become a technological leader in the US, opened its offices in 10 countries and achieved a record level of sales - 700 debt portfolios per year.
.svg){kind=icon}
.svg){kind=icon}
.svg){kind=icon}
